55 Substrate Heating Cables
Description
This article is from the Aquaria: Plants FAQ, by multiple authors.
55 Substrate Heating Cables
contributed by George Booth
Much of the mystery surrounding heating cables is that Dupla has been
careful to hide the rationale to protect their product, i.e., keep it
"magic".
I think a key concept is that we are NOT trying to mimic what happens
in nature (even though the Dupla description implies that) but we are
trying the achieve an equivalent biological affect.
In nature, you have sources of underground water moving to the surface
or surface water moving to aquifers due to natural pressure
differentials. Dupla mentions this in terms of "nutrient springs" in
tropical streams. In our aquariums, there are no such natural
pressures to cause any movement (except for UGF, etc).
The water column will tend to keep the gravel at water temperature
through conductive heating; heat will "seep" downward. However, in
glass tanks especially, the glass bottom is radiating heat into the
room, cabinet, etc, unless insulation is provided. This will tend to
keep the roots cooler than the water temperature. Even with
insulation, you'll find the bottom of the substrate cooler than the
top, just not as much.
Here is a list of substrate processes I think are important (no
particular order of importance implied):
1. Provide warmth in the substrate for certain plant species
(Barclaya longifolia, specifically). In this case the substrate
should be warmer than the water. ("hot feet")
2. Provide warmth in the substrate to speed up biochemical processes.
3. Transport nutrients from the water into the substrate. Important
nutrients would be ammonium (fish waste, etc), iron (from trace
element additions), calcium, potassium and other trace elements.
This will replenish nutrients used by the roots and provide long
term viability (in terms of years).
4. Transport harmful products out of the substrate. Decomposition
products may be harmful to plant roots. There is also conjecture
that plants give off low level toxins to keep other plants out of
their territory (successful weeds have made this an art form). If
these toxins build up due to poor circulation, the plant may harm
itself.
5. Provide a chelating medium that binds the divalent state of trace
elements with an organic molecule, enabling the trace element to
be adsorbed by root hairs.
6. Provide a reducing rather than oxidizing environment so that trace
elements are kept in their divalent state (usable by plants) or
are reduced from their oxidized trivalent state. Iron especially
will rapidly oxidize in water with normal levels of oxygen.
Heating coils provide the "hot feet" and warmth for biochemical
processes directly. The convection currents generated by the "spot"
heat source of the coils provide for nutrient and toxin transport.
Laterite in the bottom 1/3 of the substrate provides the chelating
medium. The slow convection currents, coupled with nitrifying bacteria
in the gravel will reduce the concentration of oxygen getting to the
bottom layer of the gravel, providing a reducing environment.
A heating pad under the tank will tend to warm the entire bottom layer
uniformly. This will provide hot feet and increased biochemical
activity, but I suspect the heat will go through the gravel as
conduction and won't generate convention currents. Thermodynamics
theory says that conduction will occur up to a certain heat threshold
and then convection currents will be formed with more heat. I think
the linear hot zones generated by proper spacing of the coils along
with the higher temperatures of the coils will provide this. Yes,
there will be hot and cool zones for the roots but I think the other
factors outweigh this.
Schemes that use warm water flowing in tubes in the gravel (Bioplast,
for example) won't work, IMHO, because they can't generate enough
heat. Bioplast wraps some tubing around a heater and pipes it through
the gravel with a pump. The first foot or so of the tubing may get hot
enough (though I doubt it) but the water in the coil will cool off
rather quickly as it travels through the tube. If the tube is
insulated enough to keep the water hot, then it won't transfer any
heat to the gravel.
Reverse flow undergravel filtration (RUGF) will provide increased
biochemical activity, toxin transport, and a reducing environment. It
may provide "hot feet" if you heat the water before putting it
through the RUGF. Nutrient transport is kind of difficult since the
water is usually filtered before going to the RUGF (to avoid injecting
crud into the gravel) and trace elements probably will be oxidized in
the filter (oxidizing is a bio-filter's purpose). Chelating is a
problem because a RUGF will probably push the laterite up and out of
the gravel. Don't get me wrong, a RUGF may provide the six processes,
but it would be difficult to get it set up with the right flows and
even flow across the substrate and proper mechanical filtering, etc. A
coil setup is a "no-brainer" if you have the correct wattage.
UGF will provide warmth for biochemical activity, and nutrient and
toxin transport. Hot feet would be very tricky to achieve, if not
impossible. Detritus pulled into the gravel can be chelated by the
substrate, but a reducing environment is almost impossible unless a
very slow flow is used and that would be hard to do evenly across the
whole substrate.
We have three ~100g tanks with coils and one 85g tank with UGF. All
grow plants equally well but the 85g is much more unstable. We think
it is sensitive to too much detritus building up in the gravel; a
thorough vacuuming every 6-9 months perks it up. The coil tanks
require no gravel vacuuming and the 90g tank was rock solid
biologically for at least three years. We replanted at that point
because some of the plants had gotten out of control but we didn't
"tear down" the tank - just replanted.
I think this is the key to the cables - long term stability. Plants
will grow fine without them if you can accomplish most of the six
things I mentioned. Just pulling up plants for trimming every month
will accomplish as lot (stirring up the gravel, moving roots out of
their toxin zone, etc).
Continue to:
My Books
